Judge to Decide Trump's Plan for East Potomac Park
A federal judge will render a decision this weekend on whether the Trump administration can proceed with its planned shutdown of East Potomac Park and the historic public golf course located there. The judge, U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes, signaled during a lengthy hearing on Friday that she was not ready to allow the closure, at least for the time being.
Background of the Closure and Golf Course
East Potomac Park, a 400-acre waterfront area in Washington, D.C., has long housed a public golf course operated by the National Links Trust (NLT). The NLT, a local nonprofit, managed the courses since the coronavirus pandemic. In 2023, the National Park Service terminated its lease with the NLT, creating uncertainty about the park's future. Trump's administration announced a proposed redesign of the course, featuring a new 18-hole championship layout designed by famed architect Tom Fazio. The new design would stretch more than 8,000 yards from the back tees, making it one of the largest in the country.
Critics argue that the redesign would reduce accessibility for amateur golfers who have historically enjoyed low-cost play at East Potomac. The NLT has sued to stop the redevelopment, seeking to keep the park open and to prevent the administration from cutting more trees unless they pose an imminent risk to public safety. The administration has appealed Judge Reyes's ruling that barred further tree removal without 24-hour notice.
Judge Reyes' Questions on Safety Rationale
During the hearing, Judge Reyes challenged the Justice Department's claim that the closure is necessary to address urgent public safety risks. She asked Adam Gustafson, the principal deputy assistant attorney general for DOJ's Energy and Natural Resources Division, why the closure is being justified suddenly on November 15. Reyes said, "Why all of the sudden on Nov. 15 do these justify closing down the entire park?"
Reyes also questioned the timing of the closure, noting that the park had recently hosted a Marine Corps marathon that ran directly around Hains Point. She asked, "Just days after 30,000-plus people ran around Ohio Drive, it is an emergent situation. So, tell me what happened." Gustafson deflected, citing safety concerns and the lack of an operator as justification for the imminent closure. Reyes called the latter a "self-inflicted" issue, comparing it to a person starting a fire at their home and then trying to recoup insurance money. "You're the one who set the house on fire," she told DOJ.
Potential Ethical Violations and Investigation
Judge Reyes indicated she intends to tap former U.S. Attorney for D.C. Jessie Lui to investigate whether Trump administration lawyers may have committed ethical violations during the ongoing litigation. Reyes stated, "That does not mean in any way, shape or form that I think anything untoward has happened. It only means that I think there is enough smoke that someone needs to consider whether there's been fire." The Justice Department has accused Reyes of overstepping her authority and demanded she recuse herself from the case, a request she has declined.
Legal Proceedings and Appeals
The judge is expected to rule by the end of Saturday. The Trump administration has appealed Judge Reyes's ruling to the D.C. Circuit. The case has seen a series of contentious, hours-long hearings over the project in recent months, with Judge Reyes frequently scolding DOJ officials for seemingly misrepresenting the plans as different from the president's public comments. She said, "I'm trying to figure out which iteration of me not paying attention to the president I'm supposed to go with today."
Feasibility, Cost, and Seawall Issues
Major questions about the project's feasibility and cost remain. A damaged seawall, which has been in poor condition since the Obama administration, leads to frequent flooding at the park and will cost hundreds of millions of dollars to repair. The government has so far provided few details on where financing for the seawall repair would come from, while attorneys for the administration pointed to its condition in arguing the peninsula needs to be closed off to the public. Reyes questioned what changed that required an immediate closure when deteriorating conditions have been documented for more than a decade.
Impact on Golfers and Preservationists
Preservationist group and local golfers who are suing to stop the redevelopment also want Judge Reyes to block the park from closing on Sunday, when the National Links Trust has said it would cede operational control of the courses there. "It's not, as you were saying earlier, just a massive coincidence that NLT suddenly up and decided to leave as of the very same day that the president directed defendants to close the park," argued Catherine Carroll, a lawyer representing the plaintiffs. The NLT's decision to terminate its lease last year was a key factor in the administration's move to close the park and begin construction on the new course.
What Happens Next
The judge's ruling will determine whether the Trump administration can proceed with the closure and redevelopment of East Potomac Park. If the judge allows the closure, the administration may move forward with the new championship-level golf course. If the judge blocks the closure, the park will remain open and the NLT will continue to operate the courses. The outcome will also affect ongoing investigations into potential ethical violations by Trump administration lawyers.
Related Coverage
For more on how public projects are being reshaped, see Polymarket Under Federal Review for Potential Breach of 2022 Settlement and Federal Agents Target Stolen Vehicle Network Supplying Mexican Cartels, 13 Charged.