Oti Mabuse, once hailed as the jewel of Strictly Come Dancing, has found her relationship with the show's bosses strained after a series of harsh comments aired on her podcast, The Fifth Judge. The podcast, launched with her husband Marius, was positioned as an unofficial Strictly spin-off, offering candid reviews of recent performances. However, the show's executives have expressed frustration with her tone and content, which they say veers into "unfavourable" territory and "badmouthing" the programme.
Podcast Launch and Initial Reception
In 2024, Oti Mabuse announced The Fifth Judge, a podcast featuring her husband Marius. The duo intended the series to provide an insider's perspective on the BBC's flagship dance competition, offering listeners a behind-the-scenes look at the show's choreography and judging. Early episodes focused on critiquing weekly dances, with Mabuse delivering her honest takes on the performances.
Escalating Tensions with Strictly Come Dancing
According to an insider source, the show's leadership had hoped Mabuse would maintain a respectful stance, given her continued close contact with the programme since leaving as a professional dancer. The source added that "the bosses expected her to not stray into any sort of dangerous territory." Instead, Mabuse's commentary has been described as "almost too honest" and has reportedly "badmouthing the programme."
During a recent episode, Mabuse described the show as "uncomfortable" to watch, a remark that reportedly caused a real sting backstage. She also criticised judge Shirley Ballas, claiming she was acting "mean" to attract media attention. Earlier, she made remarks about new pro dancer Maddie Ingoldsby that a source close to the dancer said left Ingoldsby hurt. Mabuse's comments included, "It's giving Dancing With The Stars but this is not Dancing With The Stars. She's done so many ballroom dances she's not listening. So she's like 'I'm going to do whatever I want,' and she's gonna get low scores."
Impact on Future Collaboration
The insider noted that the bosses have had enough of the criticism. They said, "Oti's comments have upset a lot of people on Strictly. Everyone has always backed Oti and wanted her to remain a loyal friend to the show but the sentiment has changed over recent weeks." The source added that it is unlikely she will be invited back to work on the show until the situation settles, though they remain open to a possible reconciliation in time.
Mixed Listener Feedback
Despite the backlash from the show's leadership, some listeners of The Fifth Judge have pointed out that Mabuse has also offered supportive comments on the programme. She has expressed admiration for stars such as Delta Goodrem and praised certain performances during the current series.
Official Reactions
The Sun reached out to representatives for Strictly Come Dancing and Oti Mabuse for comment. No official statements were provided in the article.
What Happens Next?
According to the insider, the relationship remains uncertain. The bosses may wait for the dust to settle before considering future collaboration, but the current situation has left the possibility of a return in doubt for the foreseeable future.