A 95-year-old widow named Mary Egan faces a £1 million legal bill following a decade-long boundary dispute with her neighbours in the affluent village of Sissinghurst, near Tunbridge Wells, in Kent. Mary Egan started fighting businessman Neil Morgan, 65, and his wife in 2016 after a major disagreement concerning the property line between their multi-million pound homes.

Details of the Ten-Year Property Conflict

Neil Morgan and his wife own a 17th century timber-framed house with a field attached to the property of Mary Egan. The legal battle centered around a 60-metre-long sliver of grass, tree and scrub measuring between a few centimetres and roughly a metre wide. After years of hostile litigation, the case ended with a county court judge declaring a score draw and ordering each side to pay their own legal costs.

High Court Appeal Dismissed

During the appeal at the High Court, barrister Daniel Petrides argued that the conduct of Neil Morgan justified the neighbours paying the seven-figure sum. However, Mr Justice Tappin ruled that despite the deplorable and unacceptable language used by Neil Morgan toward opposing lawyers, judges and court staff, the couple do not have to pay their neighbour costs. The judge noted that the dispute resulted in time, cost and energy wholly out of proportion to the financial value of the land.

How the Fence Conflict Started

Daniel Petrides explained to the court that the conflict began in September 2015 when the Morgans erected a new fence and cut through the existing wooden barrier without prior consultation. Solicitors sent warning letters regarding trespass, leading the Morgans to remove the posts, bulldoze the existing fence and install a second structure. Mary Egan subsequently cut down that second fence, prompting the installation of a temporary barrier and a third permanent fence with concrete posts in January 2016.

Court Rulings and Damages

Following a trial at Maidstone County Court in 2021, Recorder John Dagnall dismissed the claim regarding property damage from the Morgans and found them guilty of trespass for erecting the fences, awarding Mary Egan £2,600 in damages. The judge rejected the bid to remove the third fence and instead declared it the new boundary, awarding an additional £3,250 in lieu of an injunction. At a subsequent 2024 hearing, the judge ordered both parties to cover their own expenses after calling the outcome a score draw.