A 33-year-old woman reveals that the younger man she has been seeing on the side is also seeing her 28-year-old sister, creating a tangled love triangle as her boyfriend, who may propose, waits in the wings.
The woman, who prefers to remain anonymous, says her boyfriend is 35 and treats her well, cooking and remembering details, but their sex life feels predictable and dull. She began a casual affair two months ago with a handsome man in his mid-twenties after meeting him at a bar with friends. They snogged in a smoking area and later in the man's car, after which he gave her his number and offered "casual fun whenever I wanted."
Since then they have met whenever possible, usually at his flat when his housemate is out. Their chemistry has been described as "unreal," and she admits she kept telling herself she would cut him off, but he would text her and she would cave. The man's name is not disclosed, but he has become a regular presence in her life.
Her sister, aged 28, had been raving about her new man for weeks, but neither sister had met him until the last Sunday when the sister brought him to a pub. The woman's reaction was "almost dropping her drink," and both she and her sister awkwardly said "Hi." That night, the man messaged her, saying he's not serious about his sister and wants to be with her.
She reports that her boyfriend may be planning to propose to her at Christmas, adding to her confusion. She asks: "What do I do?"
Dear Deidre responds that the affair is about chemistry, not compatibility, and advises her to end the fling and be honest with her boyfriend, especially if he is about to propose. The advice includes investing in the current relationship, exploring new sexual experiences together, or ending things with the boyfriend if deeper issues exist. She suggests the support pack "Thrilling A Woman In Bed" to help with sexual fulfillment.
In a separate section, the woman recounts a breakup with a wife six months ago, a fling with a woman at work, and subsequent custody and care responsibilities. She was 42, her wife 40, and they have two primary-school children. After a hysterectomy, her wife asked her to move back in to help with recovery, which she did for two months. The wife is now fully recovered and has asked her to move out again, leaving the woman feeling hurt and used.
Dear Deidre advises the woman that her wife saw her as an excellent carer and co-parent, and suggests couples counseling with Tavistock Relationships (020 7380 1975) to rebuild the marriage if she chooses to stay.
Finally, a 28-year-old woman expresses anxiety about being a "proper" man, fearing she is not good enough because she is skinny, scared of spiders, and not a good driver. She has never had a girlfriend and worries about not meeting societal expectations of masculinity.
Dear Deidre counters that many men do not drive or have big muscles, and that people on social media present unrealistic facades. She recommends driving refresher lessons or an Advanced Driving Course, and offers a support pack on "Fears And Phobias" for overcoming phobias. She encourages embracing imperfections in relationships.
Background on Dear Deidre and the Advice Industry
Dear Deidre is a UK-based online relationship advice brand that offers free counseling via WhatsApp, email, and social media. The brand's website lists contact numbers and links to WhatsApp and email for confidential support. It markets support packs such as "Thrilling A Woman In Bed" and "Fears And Phobias," which are downloadable guides aimed at addressing specific relationship and personal development issues.
The advice industry in the United Kingdom has grown rapidly in the past decade, with many online platforms offering personalized counseling and downloadable content. These services often emphasize quick, actionable tips and are marketed directly to individuals seeking immediate solutions to relationship challenges.
What the Woman's Situation Reveals About Modern Relationships
Modern relationships frequently involve overlapping social circles and digital communication that can blur boundaries. Casual encounters, often facilitated by dating apps or social venues, can lead to complex entanglements when participants have close family ties. In this case, the woman's casual lover is also dating her sister, creating a scenario that tests loyalty, honesty, and emotional boundaries.
The potential proposal from her boyfriend adds another layer of complexity. Proposals are traditionally seen as a commitment to monogamy, yet the woman's current sexual dissatisfaction and the existence of a casual affair complicate the decision to accept or decline. The advice offered stresses honesty and communication as essential steps before a significant commitment.
Potential Legal and Emotional Implications
While no legal actions are mentioned, the situation could have emotional repercussions for all parties involved. The woman's boyfriend may feel betrayed if the affair becomes public. Her sister may experience hurt or confusion if the man's feelings shift. The woman's own mental health could be affected by the stress of managing multiple relationships and impending proposals.
What Happens Next According to the Advice
Dear Deidre's guidance suggests the woman should first decide whether to end the casual affair or attempt to improve her current relationship's intimacy. If she chooses to stay with her boyfriend, she should communicate her sexual needs and explore new experiences together. If she decides the affair is a sign of deeper dissatisfaction, she should end her relationship with her boyfriend before he proposes, thereby avoiding a painful surprise.
Should she decide to stay with her boyfriend, the advice implies that the casual lover's feelings for her sister may become clearer once she is no longer in the picture. The woman may then reassess the man's role in her life and possibly end the affair altogether.
How the Advice Addresses Similar Issues
In the second anecdote, the woman who was 42 and had a wife who underwent a hysterectomy received guidance on navigating post-hospital care responsibilities and the emotional fallout of a breakup. The advice underscores the importance of addressing underlying issues and seeking couples counseling to rebuild trust.
The third anecdote, involving a 28-year-old man's insecurities about masculinity, highlights how Dear Deidre addresses self-esteem and relationship readiness by offering practical resources and encouraging self-acceptance.
Why This Story Matters
For anyone in a relationship who feels sexual dissatisfaction or is juggling multiple romantic interests, this story provides a concrete example of how to handle complex emotional entanglements. It also illustrates how professional advice platforms can offer structured guidance on sensitive topics such as infidelity, commitment, and personal insecurities.
Key Takeaways
The woman discovered her casual lover is also seeing her sister, complicating her relationship with her boyfriend who may propose. She is advised to end the affair or improve intimacy with her boyfriend before a proposal. The advice includes practical support packs and counseling resources. A similar scenario involving a breakup and caregiving responsibilities shows the importance of addressing underlying issues. A separate case highlights the need for self-acceptance and practical steps to overcome personal phobias.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What should I do if my casual lover is also dating my sister?
Seek honest communication with all parties involved and consider ending the affair if it creates conflict. - How can I improve sexual satisfaction with my boyfriend?
Discuss desires, try new experiences together, and use available support packs to guide conversations. - Is it okay to end a relationship before a proposal?
Yes, honesty is preferable to a surprise rejection on a proposal day.