Voters Deliver Clear Message on Biological Reality

Voters were not subtle last Tuesday as they rejected the current direction of the country while focusing heavily on biological reality alongside economic concerns. In the months ahead, both parties will study what worked and what did not during an election cycle where citizens demanded integrity, competence, and principle.

The clearest proof of this shift is the success of state ballot measures protecting girls sports and spaces. Arizona voters passed a measure that builds on existing state law keeping women sports for women by defining sex by an original birth certificate and extending protections to private spaces and athletic associations.

Nebraska voters wrote their 2025 law into their state constitution to require K-12 and higher education schools to designate teams as male, female, or co-ed. This constitutional amendment keeps women sports free from men claiming a female identity.

State Ballot Measures Pass in Colorado and Washington

Voters in Colorado and Washington also approved measures protecting children, with Colorado passing protections for girls sports alongside another measure shielding children from dangerous transition surgeries. In Washington, voters went to the ballot box to say by double digits that girls deserve fairness, safety, and privacy.

This outcome is significant in a state that has made women sports headlines all year following incidents at local athletic events. At a Seattle Storm Women National Basketball Association game, the team co-owner spewed obscenities at young girls wearing XX-XY Athletics shirts in support of the ballot measure and Sophie Cunningham calling for safety for women and girls.

In Puyallup, Washington, state and school officials allowed a male wrestler to compete against then-15-year-old wrestler Kallie Keeler, resulting in serious harm that led to an emergency petition pending before the Supreme Court of the United States. In Camas, a male athlete who switched to the girls cross country team midyear took the final qualifying spot from a deserving young woman from Puyallup High School and competed in the women state finals this month.

Legal Battles Over Girls Sports Protections

Despite these documented harms, many elected officials in Washington and Colorado have criticized these ballot measures despite voters electing them. The American Civil Liberties Union has asked a Washington judge to undo the people vote and strip away protections for girls.

The American Civil Liberties Union cannot erase truth or change biology, prompting Alliance Defending Freedom to file a motion to intervene to defend Washington new law on behalf of young female athletes. Alliance Defending Freedom Chief Executive Officer, President, and Chief Counsel Kristen Waggoner noted that our daughters have been told to sit on the sidelines as spectators in their own sports for far too long.

Pundits will dissect this election for months, but basic facts like biological differences remain constant. Voters protected female athletes on November 3, and advocates intend to defend those protections against ongoing legal challenges from activists.

Background on State Sports Policies

State-level debates over transgender athletes in women sports have accelerated across the United States over recent years. Numerous state legislatures have introduced and passed bills restricting transgender female athletes from competing on teams that align with their gender identity rather than their sex assigned at birth. Proponents argue these policies are necessary to ensure fair competition and safety for biological females, while opponents argue such restrictions discriminate against transgender youth and violate civil rights protections. The legal landscape continues to evolve as federal courts review Title IX interpretations and state-level constitutional amendments.

The Role of Advocacy Groups and Litigation

Legal organizations on both sides of the debate have engaged in extensive courtroom battles over school sports policies and gender-affirming care restrictions. Civil rights organizations like the American Civil Liberties Union frequently challenge state laws restricting transgender athletes or healthcare access, arguing they violate equal protection guarantees. Conversely, groups like Alliance Defending Freedom represent female athletes and state governments in defending regulations that separate sports categories based on biological sex. These court battles increasingly involve federal agencies, state education departments, and local school boards navigating conflicting legal standards and federal guidance.