President Trump is securing a lasting legal legacy in defamation litigation during his final two years in office, recently landing two significant victories against The New York Times and the BBC. U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday and Judge Jeffrey Kuntz issued rulings allowing the lawsuits to proceed to trial, which could establish important precedents for future defamation cases if upheld on appeal.
The New York Times Defamation Lawsuit
In the case of Trump v. New York Times, Trump is suing the publication for $15 billion over an article titled “Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success.” Judge Steven D. Merryday permitted four of the seven original claims to move toward trial, requiring the Times to answer allegations that reporters Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner defamed the President.
The court challenged the newspaper for relying on three experts without a solid evidentiary foundation for the article's claims of potential tax fraud and money laundering. Merryday pointed to the statements of Lee-Ford Tritt, Adam S. Kaufmann, and Mitchell Gans, noting that publishing superficial characterizations without a thorough examination of pertinent facts could constitute the purposeful avoidance of the truth.
The BBC Defamation Case in Florida
In a separate legal challenge, Judge Jeffrey Kuntz allowed the Trump v. BBC case to proceed after finding sufficient evidence of actual malice. Trump sued the British media outlet over a documentary titled “Trump: A Second Chance,” which aired a week before the 2024 election and spliced together two lines from a speech given on January 6, 2021.
The broadcast combined statements uttered 55 minutes apart to make it appear as though Trump was inciting supporters to riot, omitting his explicit call for followers to march peacefully. Kuntz noted that the time disparity between the statements creates a plausible inference that the network knew the segment was not truthful.