Legally, there is a strange disconnect between how this country treats the crime of murder and how it treats the crime of sexually abusing a child. In too many jurisdictions, accused child-abusers are granted legal protections and advantages that people who have been accused of murder do not have access to.
Yet, in numerous surveys, most adults rank the crime of rape as roughly equivalent to that of murder. The crime of raping a child stands at the very summit of most people's ideas of criminality at its most horrific. Legal minds and policymakers from across the political spectrum agree on this. In the wake of the controversial Supreme Court decision in 2008's Kennedy vs. Louisiana, presidential candidate Barack Obama found himself agreeing with Justice Samuel Alito's dissent, in which he wrote, "In the eyes of ordinary Americans, the very worst child-rapists ... are the epitome of moral depravity."
Statutes of limitations protect child abusers
Yet in many parts of the U.S., those who rape children are protected by statutes of limitations. Unlike murderers, they cannot be made to stand trial for their crimes after a certain number of years has passed. In more than half of the U.S., that limit is pegged to the age of the victim. In other words, once victims pass that age, ranging anywhere from 24 to 55, they lose the right to bring charges against their attackers. In many cases, they even expose themselves to slander charges by going public with their claims after the lapse of many years.
This is a big problem for victims. If someone is murdered, a corpse is usually enough to trigger a criminal investigation. But when children are sexually abused, they need to file convincing reports with the proper authorities for anything to happen. Studies have shown that more than half of the victims of child sexual abuse wait until they are past the age of 50 before they come forward. It is common for abusers to swear the children to secrecy and threaten them with further consequences in the event of disclosure. The shame and trauma of the attack are usually enough on their own to ensure silence for years to come.
Personal accounts reveal the failure of the legal system
In my own case, after being raped by my violin professor at the Curtis Institute of Music in Philadelphia when I was 14, I made all of the usual mistakes. For months, I closed up, kept to myself and did nothing. Then I asked the dean to give me a new teacher. He scoffed at the idea and dragged his feet on taking action. After another painful year, I attempted suicide and then left Curtis. Decades passed before I went public with my story, in a cover feature in The Philadelphia Inquirer in 2019.
Unfortunately, even though Pennsylvania passed a new law that year setting the higher cutoff age of 55 for childhood victims of sexual abuse to file charges, this applied only to new cases. It did nothing for people like me or other past victims of abuse. Under the applicable laws at the time, I had two years from the time of the attack in 1986 to file charges. The deadline expired when I was 16, emotionally and financially broken. It's ridiculous to imagine that I could have lawyered up and done anything concrete to stop my attacker at that time.
Why federal legislation is needed
Child rapists know this. They go after the most vulnerable kids, and they understand exactly how to game the laws that are intended to deter them. The institutions that shelter these people have also shown a keen awareness of just how much, or how little, is required of them to fulfill their obligations under the law. And that is why federal legislation is needed to close the loopholes and harmonize the hodgepodge of laws against sexual abuse of children abuse that currently exist in the U.S.
There is no divergence of public opinion on whether the sexual abuse of children is good or bad. There is a rock-solid consensus across the political spectrum that it should be stamped out as much as possible. Childhood sex abuse ruins lives. It is more pernicious than simple murder. There are certain circumstances in which killing someone is fully defensible, ethically and under the law, but no one ever raped a child in self-defense.
The only force standing in the way of justice for victims is a narrow set of vested institutional interests seeking to limit their financial exposure to potential claims. That is not a good enough reason to protect child-rapists. American voters do not want their elected representatives to protect criminals. Congress needs to take action and strip them of their protections once and for all.
Lara St. John is a violinist and filmmaker. Her documentary, "Dear Lara," on sexual abuse at music schools will be screened at the Alexandria Film Festival on Nov. 15.
Background on statutes of limitations in criminal law
Statutes of limitations represent laws passed by legislative bodies to set the maximum time after an event within which legal proceedings may be initiated. While murder charges typically carry no statute of limitations in the United States due to the severity of the crime and the permanence of the loss, many other offenses historically included time limits. These limits were originally justified by the declining reliability of evidence, the fading memories of witnesses, and the difficulty of mounting a proper defense as decades pass. However, advances in forensic science and a deeper understanding of psychological trauma have driven many states to reevaluate these time restrictions for serious offenses.
The psychological impact of severe trauma often prevents victims from reporting crimes immediately. Child sexual abuse survivors frequently experience complex post-traumatic stress disorder, dissociation, and intense feelings of shame or self-blame that can last for decades. Sociological research consistently demonstrates that victims need extended periods, often well into adulthood, to process their experiences before feeling safe enough to disclose them to law enforcement or family members. When legal frameworks fail to account for these psychological realities, perpetrators continue to benefit from the silence enforced by their own abuse.
Institutional liability and the legal reforms
Educational institutions, religious organizations, and youth groups have historically faced significant financial and reputational liabilities when allegations of abuse surface. Legal battles often center on whether institutions exercised proper oversight or ignored warning signs regarding predatory staff members. Reform advocates argue that these institutional self-preservation instincts drive intense lobbying efforts to preserve shorter windows for civil suits and criminal prosecutions. Without federal intervention, the legal landscape remains fragmented, leaving survivors with vastly different rights depending entirely on geographic location.