Lawmakers File Bipartisan Class-Action Lawsuit Over Pay

Several members of Congress are heading to court this week in an under-the-radar lawsuit claiming they have been underpaid. It is a bipartisan issue, with Democrats like Rep. James Clyburn (S.C.) and Republicans like Rep. Rick Crawford (Ark.) joining as plaintiffs.

Ratified in 1992, the 27th Amendment states that no law varying the compensation of members of Congress shall take effect until an election has intervened. Clyburn, Crawford and other lawmakers argue their colleagues violated this provision by waiving automatic cost-of-living adjustments to keep rank-and-file salaries steady at $174,000 since 2009.

Attorney Ken Cuccinelli represents Crawford in the litigation. U.S. Court of Federal Claims Judge Eric Bruggink is presiding over the case, which features scheduled arguments set for 10 a.m. EST on Thursday.

Key Legal Questions Facing the Court

Judge Bruggink must resolve several complex issues during the proceedings. The central questions include determining when an election intervenes under the constitutional amendment, evaluating whether the congressional cost-of-living adjustment formula constitutes a law varying pay, and establishing the exact years for which the plaintiffs can seek damages.

The federal government maintains that an election intervenes as long as the relevant law passes before Election Day. Conversely, the plaintiffs argue that once the first ballot is cast weeks earlier, enacting such a measure comes too late.