During the 2024 Federalist Society annual gathering, conservative legal leaders toasted recent Supreme Court triumphs while reacting to Democrats' unexpected victories in traditionally red states such as Mississippi, Kansas and Texas. The event, held in Washington, D.C., blended celebration with uncertainty about the future of the Trump administration's judicial agenda.
Conference Highlights and Political Shock
The convention opened with a champagne toast that echoed last year's celebratory moment when panelists cheered Supreme Court wins. Despite the festive atmosphere, attendees were visibly stunned by the midterm outcomes that saw Democrats capture the Senate and flip key statewide offices.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio, speaking to the crowd, joked, "On election night, there was a congressman who said we all need to lawyer up. So, here we are," before delivering the Barbara K. Olson Memorial Lecture. He urged participants not to be discouraged, stating, "Great things that last are built in decades, not election cycles."
The Federalist Society's Rise and Influence
The Federalist Society, founded by law students in the 1980s to counter liberal ideology on campuses, has evolved into a pipeline for conservative legal talent. Its alumni now occupy prominent law firms, government roles and judicial seats. The Society's 40-year history includes shaping the Trump administration's Supreme Court nominations.
Leonard Leo, the Society's long-time leader, built a donor network that produced the lists President Trump used to pick Justices Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. These appointments cemented a 6-3 conservative majority, the Society's crowning achievement.
Trump, Leo and the Current Judicial Tension
After President Trump's re-election, he publicly clashed with Leo over nominees who opposed his agenda. In 2023, Trump labeled Leo a "sleazebag," sparking debate over future judicial appointments. With the Senate now controlled by Democrats, Republican senators are racing to confirm remaining vacancies before the January 2025 transition.
Red-State Defeats Shock the Conservative Legal Community
Democrats' sweeping wins in Mississippi and Kansas left many attendees disoriented. A lawyer remarked, "Did you think it would be this bad?" after learning his lunch companion was from Texas. The party also captured Texas's open Senate seat, gubernatorial race, multiple supreme court positions and the attorney general's office.
Maríah Cermone, president emerita of the Society's Texas student chapter, noted the state's new political dynamic while introducing a Republican justice for the opening address. She remarked, "Even though Texans have taken to troubleshooting their grievances by holding their breath till they happen to turn blue, I must say that I still choose Texas every day of the week and twice on Sunday," adding she is a native Floridian.
John Yoo, a conservative law professor currently at UC Berkeley and slated to join the University of Texas next year, joked, "I can't even find a red state to move to," calling the results "stunning". He criticized the midterm outcomes, saying, "I think the American people supported President Trump's effort to restore order at the border, but gosh, I think that the challenge to birthright citizenship was a serious mistake." He further condemned overaggressive immigration enforcement, noting it led to the deaths of two American citizens.
Celebrating 250 Years and Supreme Court Wins
The convention also honored the United States' 250th birthday with a themed bar and merchandise. Despite the political setbacks, the event celebrated the conservative movement's Supreme Court victories, including rulings on presidential firing power, the Voting Rights Act, transgender athlete bans and Hawaii's gun restrictions.
Alliance for Consumers Executive Director O.H. Skinner moderated a session and distributed commemorative coins to attendees, each featuring one of the four decisions. Skinner's note praised the Court's commitment to expanding past generational wins and tackling new societal questions.
Keynote by Justice Samuel Alito
Justice Samuel Alito delivered the keynote at the annual dinner, referencing the Supreme Court's recent term. He cautioned that Congress could defund the Court, warning, "Congress can turn off the lights at the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they want to defund their activities. And there are many, many, many other things that they can do, or at least try to do."
Alito reflected on two decades of rulings, celebrating decisions on abortion, religious rights and other major issues. He emphasized the Court's aim to return to the Constitution's original structure, noting, "How that is going to play out in the future, and how far it should play out in the future, and whether, those are open questions." He concluded, "But those are all very important questions."
Optimism Amid Uncertainty
Despite the mixed emotions, many participants maintained an optimistic tone. Will Schwieterman, a University of Chicago law student, said, "This is not the end of our country that we had, you know, one bad midterm performance. It's only the end if we stop fighting for what we believe in, stop standing for the Constitution, and you know, just kind of accept things as how they are."
What Happens Next for the Federalist Society?
With the Senate now in Democratic hands, the Society's influence on future judicial appointments faces new challenges. Republican senators are working to confirm remaining vacancies before the January 2025 transition. Meanwhile, the Society continues to support conservative legal education and policy initiatives, aiming to sustain its pipeline of conservative lawyers.
Related Coverage
Democratic lawmakers face backlash following legislative missteps
Democratic gains in midterms won't fully restore abortion rights