Former midfielder Paul Ince has claimed that the Manchester United squad lacks physical power in the middle of the pitch and accused the club of wasting 50 million pounds on Andrey Santos. The former Old Trafford star described the Red Devils as a basket case that is far too lightweight in central areas.
During a recent transfer window, the club brought in Santos from Chelsea, Youri Tielemans from Aston Villa, and Carlos Baleba from Brighton as part of a 155 million pound midfield revamp. These three players have competed alongside Kobbie Mainoo and club captain Bruno Fernandes for three central roles.
This squad dilemma is just one of many challenges facing new head coach Mauricio Pochettino as he begins his tenure after arriving from the United States. Ince won seven trophies during six years at Old Trafford and shared his blunt assessment regarding the current personnel.
"Fernandes is a world-class player but has got no legs," Ince told SunSport via Freebets.com. "Mainoo, he's got no legs. So where are the legs in the middle of the park? If you're going to be a top team, you've got to have legs. Those players, they're not powerful. They've got no legs. The times you see them running back to their goal."
Brazilian midfielder Santos, 22, moved to Old Trafford in July even though Chelsea had sent him out on loan four times and mostly used him as a squad option. High-level club sources indicated that Santos was quite far down the recruitment list, though management pursued him because he matched their preferred age profile and possessed Premier League experience.
Tielemans, 29, has struggled to reach top form since changing clubs, while 22-year-old Baleba is currently sidelined with a hamstring injury. Baleba picked up the physical issue during a dramatic 3-2 comeback victory over Roma in the Champions League a fortnight ago.
Santos has managed only four starts across ten Premier League fixtures for the Red Devils and remained an unused substitute during the entertaining 4-4 draw with Aston Villa before the international break. Ince questioned the logic behind the major outlay on the Brazilian prospect.
"Why did they spend £50m on Santos? That's £50m wasted. They could have put that into the defence or bought a striker," Ince added. "They have Mainoo, who needs to develop. He needs to be playing, not Santos. Tielemans, again, fantastic at Villa but it's a different conversation when you come to United. Baleba didn't play a lot last year. He comes in for £70m, plays a couple of games and he's injured again."
The former England international emphasized that modern football requires physical intensity and defensive work rate rather than simple passing combinations. He noted that elite managers constantly stress the importance of winning individual battles across the pitch.
"The game's changing. It's not all pass, pass, pass now. You've got to win your duels. You used to hear Pep Guardiola say every time, 'We didn't win our duels, we didn't win our tackles'. The game's more physical, more powerful," Ince stated.
The financial outlay by the Red Devils on Tielemans, Santos, and Baleba was significantly smaller than the massive spending undertaken by rival Manchester City. City rebuilt their midfield by investing 326.6 million pounds to secure Elliot Anderson, Enzo Fernandez, and Ayyoub Bouaddi following the absence of World Cup winner Rodri. Meanwhile, reigning Premier League champions Arsenal strengthened their squad by paying Newcastle United 75 million pounds for Bruno Guimaraes.
Declan Rice wanted to join the Red Devils five years ago, but the club failed to make an offer before the midfielder eventually moved to West Ham and later joined Arsenal for 105 million pounds in 2023. Ince compared current recruitment issues with the caliber of players required at an elite level.
"Declan Rice is world class. He gets up and down. What you've got is players playing for Manchester United, not Manchester United players. That's a big difference. Who's a Manchester United player out there? Rice, Jude Bellingham. They are who you should be going for. Since Sir Alex Ferguson left it's been a complete disaster. Would every player in the world want to come to United? They don't, because it's a basket case there, a shambles," Ince concluded.
Background on Manchester United Recruitment Struggles
Manchester United have experienced a turbulent period in the transfer market since legendary manager Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013. Despite spending vast sums on various squads, the club has struggled to secure consistent domestic or continental success. Analysts and former players frequently criticize the club's recruitment strategy for lacking a cohesive long-term vision, often paying inflated fees for players who fail to meet the historical standards of the institution.
The Evolution of Premier League Midfield Physicality
Modern English football places extreme demands on central midfielders, requiring elite aerobic capacity and defensive resilience alongside technical skill. Clubs competing at the top of the Premier League table routinely invest heavily in athletic profiles capable of covering ground rapidly and winning physical duels. The success of rival teams demonstrates that controlling the central areas requires high-intensity runners who can transition seamlessly between defensive duties and attacking phases.