Two police officers who lied about the hunt for two missing women before they were found in a crashed car have been sacked. Rafel Jeanne, who was driving at the time, and passengers Darcy Ross and Eve Smith, both 21, all died in the horror in St Mellons, Cardiff. Two further passengers, Sophie Russon, 20, and Shane Loughlin, 32, were injured but survived. The five friends were discovered around 46 hours after the Volkswagen Tiguan they were travelling in left the road and smashed into trees on a roundabout. PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone have now been found guilty of gross misconduct over their actions before the group was found.
Disciplinary Hearing Details in Newport
Panel chairman Ian Arundale said a final written warning was not an option as he sacked both officers at the hearing in Newport. The pair had been dishonest in official logs and to a senior officer by claiming searches of Eve and Sophie homes had been carried out when they had not. The horror unfolded on March 4, 2023, as the friends made their way back from a night out. The car is understood to have left the road on a slip road on the A48 as it approached a roundabout. Darcy mother and Sophie father went to Newport central police station to report their children missing on the evening of the crash.
Assigned Tasks and Missing Person Protocols
The hearing was told PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone were given the straightforward task of attending two home addresses to take any details from family members and to search. Stephen Morley, for Gwent Police professional standards department, said this was something that should always happen during a missing person enquiry and was common sense. He told the panel searches are carried out to assess whether the missing person might actually be at home or if they had left or taken something important with them. PC Livingstone had been assigned to search Sophie house, while PC Hardwick was tasked with going to Darcy home.
Discrepancies in Official Police Logs
The first officer said she had first spoken to Smith brother and then her mother before noting down that nothing out of the usual was missing. She added that mum and dad were concerned and mum believed she went out in the same clothes and has not taken any new clothes with her. But the panel were told this was a dishonest and misleading entry. In her risk assessment of Darcy as a missing person, PC Livingstone answered no in the section about whether her disappearance was out of character. The officer wrote that they had gone out to what appears to be a party and stayed out longer than what they should have been. There are videos of the girls on Snapchat together and they appear to be in high spirits. The only concerning thing is that they are not answering their phones.
False Claims Made to Supervising Officers
PC Hardwick claimed he had searched the premises, which Mr Morley also said was a lie. The hearing was told both officers were said to have updated a colleague overseeing the investigation that the searches had taken place. But the families of both women said these had not taken place, it was alleged. Mr Morley said that while their actions may not have made any difference to the tragic outcome, that was neither here nor there as these officers are expected do a proper job. It was a serious failing, he added.
Panel Findings and Dismissal Rulings
The panel found both officers had failed to conduct a search at Darcy and Sophie homes. They also ruled Livingstone and Hardwick gave a dishonest account of the search to their supervisors. Mr Arundale said the behaviour had caused harm because of the impact on the family and had undermined public trust in the police. Derrick Campbell, from the Independent Office for Police Conduct, said the officers failed to act honestly and with integrity. He added that PC Hardwick deliberately lied during the course of the missing person investigation, claiming on police records and to his supervisor that searches had been completed. PC Livingstone had ample opportunity to tell the Independent Office for Police Conduct the required searches had not been conducted. Instead, she did not give an account and stated she could not remember the specifics of her visits to the homes of two of the young women who had been reported missing.
Background on Missing Persons Procedures in United Kingdom Policing
Police forces across the United Kingdom follow strict national guidelines when handling missing person reports to ensure the safety of vulnerable individuals. Officers are trained to assess risk levels immediately upon receiving a report from concerned relatives or friends. Standard operating procedures dictate that initial enquiries must include checking local hospitals, contacting known associates, and inspecting the home addresses of the missing parties. These baseline actions help establish a timeline, gather clues regarding mental state or preparation for travel, and secure contact numbers or digital devices. Failing to execute these fundamental duties compromises the entire investigative response from the outset.
The Role of Professional Standards Departments
Professional standards departments within British police forces investigate allegations of misconduct, corruption, and sub-standard performance by officers and staff. When potential breaches of the police standards of professional behaviour are identified, internal investigators gather evidence, interview witnesses, and compile case files for misconduct hearings. These independent panels possess the authority to impose sanctions ranging from written warnings to immediate dismissal without notice. The oversight process aims to maintain high ethical standards, protect public confidence, and hold accountable any personnel who fall short of their sworn oath to serve and protect communities fairly and honestly.