A 37-year-old mother who held her one-year-old daughter above the waves as the 184-ft Bayesian mega-yacht capsized off Sicily in August 2024 has accused the crew of acting recklessly, leaving her and her partner to find safety on their own. Seven people, including tech magnate Mike Lynch, died in the incident.

Who is involved?

Charlotte Golunski, 37, a partner at Lynch's investment firm Invoke Capital, and her partner James Emslie are the central figures in the lawsuit. Their one-year-old daughter was aboard the yacht at the time of the disaster. The yacht's owner, Mike Lynch, 59, a former "Britain's Bill Gates" tech entrepreneur, was also on board. The incident occurred on the night of August 2024, when the Bayesian, a 184-ft sailing vessel with a 72-metre mast, capsized off the coast of Sicily.

What happened?

According to the High Court paperwork obtained by The Sun, the crew failed to sound an alarm, provide a safety briefing, or show passengers how to use life-jackets. The captain was reportedly asleep as the storm intensified, and an order to abandon ship was not issued until it was too late. The couple claims the yacht could not withstand hurricane-force winds because of its large mast and that the retractable keel was not fully lowered, leaving the vessel unstable when 70-knot winds struck.

How did the family survive?

Ms Golunski says she held her baby above the water in the dark until a life raft inflated. She recalled, "For two seconds I lost my daughter in the sea then quickly hugged her amid the fury of the waves." She added, "I held her afloat with all my strength, my arms stretched upwards to keep her from drowning." She also said, "It was all dark. In the water I couldn't keep my eyes open. I screamed for help but all I could hear around me was the screams of others."

Legal claims and alleged crew failures

Ms Golunski and Mr Emslie have listed 18 alleged crew failures, including: a failure to position the yacht in a safe location overnight; a failure to maintain an adequate overnight watch; a failure to provide an adequate safety briefing; a failure to sound the emergency alarm; failed emergency lighting; no distress flare; and life rafts launched too late. The defence claims the crew did not order guests to muster or abandon ship until it was too late, leaving the family to scramble for safety with very limited assistance from the captain and crew.

Ownership and compensation fight

Revtom Limited, the Isle of Man-based company that owned the £30 million yacht, is attempting to limit the amount of compensation it must pay under a centuries-old shipping law. The company has named the couple and their toddler as defendants in a limitation of liability claim lodged in the Admiralty Court in September. The move pits Lynch's widow, Angela Bacares, 58, against the friends and colleagues her husband invited aboard to celebrate his acquittal on fraud charges. Other victims include his daughter Hannah, 18; Morgan Stanley International chairman Jonathan Bloomer and his wife Judy; lawyer Chris Morvillo and his wife Neda; and chef Recaldo Thomas.

Investigation findings

Italian investigators concluded the Bayesian sank because of crew incompetence rather than design faults. Prosecutors in Sicily believe the retractable keel had not been fully lowered, leaving the yacht unstable when 70-knot winds struck. The final report is expected within weeks, after which prosecutors are expected to seek trials for captain James Cutfield, chief engineer Tim Parker Eaton and deckhand Matthew Griffiths over manslaughter and culpable shipwreck.

Background on Mike Lynch

Mike Lynch, once worth £850 million, was cleared over allegations he inflated the value of his British tech firm Autonomy when he sold it to HP for £7.4 billion. Earlier this year the High Court ordered his estate to pay Hewlett Packard £920 million over the sale, nearly double its estimated £500 million value. The Italian Sea Group, owner of the Perini Navi shipyard that built the Bayesian, filed a claim of up to £400 million in Sicily in January against Revtom.

What next?

The couple have sent a formal letter of claim to yacht managers Camper & Nicholsons, who hired the crew, in April, and intend to sue for personal injury. They say the firm has refused to hand over design, stability and crew records, or to disclose how much insurance sits behind the fund. The allegations echo the findings of Italian investigators, who last week concluded the Bayesian sank because of crew incompetence rather than design faults.

Links to related stories

Background on the Bayesian

The Bayesian was built by Perini Navi in Italy and launched in 2020. It is a large-mast sailing yacht designed for luxury cruising. The vessel's 72-metre mast and retractable keel are intended to provide stability and performance, but investigators now argue that the keel was not fully lowered during the storm, compromising the yacht's balance.

What the law says about compensation

Under the UK's Admiralty Law, owners of a vessel can limit liability for damages if they can prove that the damage was not caused by reckless conduct. If a judge finds that owners acted recklessly, the right to cap payouts is lost. Revtom Limited is seeking a judge to cap payouts to survivors and bereaved families, but the couple's claims argue that the owners knew the yacht's stability fell short of what its paperwork claimed and allowed it to sail anyway.

Implications for the shipping industry

The incident highlights the importance of proper safety briefings, emergency alarms and crew readiness, especially when sailing in areas prone to sudden weather changes. The case may prompt stricter regulatory oversight of yacht operations and crew training in Italy and the UK.

What the victims' families are seeking

Ms Golunski and Mr Emslie are seeking compensation for injuries sustained during the incident. They also argue that the yacht's design, specification and manufacture were unsuitable and inadequate for its intended use as a large-mast sailing yacht, creating a foreseeable risk of capsizing.

Legal strategy and potential outcomes

Revtom Limited's strategy is to argue that the yacht's owners did not act recklessly and that the incident was due to crew incompetence. If the court sides with the plaintiffs, the owners may be required to pay full compensation for all victims. If the court sides with the defendants, the owners could limit payouts under the centuries-old shipping law.

Key points

  • Charlotte Golunski held her one-year-old daughter above the waves as the Bayesian sank.
  • Seven people died, including tech mogul Mike Lynch, 59.
  • Revtom Limited, owner of the £30 million yacht, is seeking to limit compensation under Admiralty Law.
  • Italian investigators attribute the sinking to crew incompetence, not design faults.
  • Prosecutors plan to trial the captain, chief engineer and deckhand for manslaughter and culpable shipwreck.

Why it matters

The case affects the families of the victims and the owners of luxury yachts, highlighting the legal responsibilities of yacht operators and the potential consequences of inadequate safety measures.

FAQ

  • What caused the Bayesian to capsize? Italian investigators say crew incompetence, not design faults, caused the sinking. The retractable keel was not fully lowered, leaving the yacht unstable when 70-knot winds struck.
  • Who is seeking compensation? Charlotte Golunski and James Emslie are suing for personal injury and compensation for injuries sustained during the incident.
  • What is the legal claim against Revtom Limited? Revtom Limited, the owner of the yacht, is being sued in Admiralty Court to limit payouts under a centuries-old shipping law, but the plaintiffs argue the owners acted recklessly.