In the aftermath of the 2024 election, criticism of President Trump's tariff policy has intensified. A new study by Caroline Freund, dean of the University of California-San Diego's School of Global Policy and Strategy, argues that foreign exporters have absorbed almost half of the tariff burden by cutting prices, challenging the narrative that consumers bear the full cost.

Who Conducted the Study and What It Shows

Caroline Freund's analysis focuses on the 2025 tariff shock. She finds that foreign exporters, rather than U.S. importers, have taken a significant share of the cost. According to Freund, exporters cut prices by an average of 22 percent when tariffs increased by 28 percentage points, with examples such as Chinese toy exporters and South Korean automakers.

Comparing Different Research Findings

Other studies paint a different picture. A New York Fed analysis estimated that U.S. importers shouldered 86-94 percent of the tariff burden through November 2025. Germany's Kiel Institute reported an even higher domestic share of 96 percent. These figures differ from Freund's because they treat small product-country trade relationships the same as large ones, without weighting by economic value.

Methodological Distinction: Weighting by Economic Value

Freund corrects for this by weighting trade by economic value and limiting her scope to the 50 largest U.S. trading partners, which account for more than 95 percent of U.S. goods imports. This approach gives a more accurate picture of how tariffs affect major exporters.

Exporters' Ability to Defend Market Share

Freund's insight is that dominant exporters, unlike marginal suppliers, have the margins and market share to defend their positions by cutting prices when tariffs rise. This aligns with statements from President Trump and senior White House trade officials that big exporters such as China, Vietnam, and Europe depend heavily on the U.S. market and thus absorb much of the tariff cost.

Concrete Examples of Price Cuts

In her study, Chinese toy and doll exporters faced a 28-percentage-point tariff increase and cut prices by 22 percent. South Korean automakers, with a 22-point increase, reduced prices by 12 percent. Indian cotton bedsheet producers, also facing a 28-point increase, lowered prices by 16 percent.

Impact on American Consumers and Inflation

Freund does not claim that tariffs impose zero costs on Americans. However, her findings undermine the anti-tariff argument that foreign exporters never absorb a meaningful share. President Trump has stated that since tariffs began in 2018, there is no credible evidence that consumers have borne the full burden critics claim, nor that tariffs are the main driver of today's inflation. The argument is that major exporters must absorb much of the tariff cost rather than passing it on to consumers.

Political Context: Voter Attitudes and Inflation Concerns

Exit polls from November's election show why the tariff debate matters politically. Sixty-six percent of voters said Trump's tariffs hurt the national economy; 79 percent said inflation caused their families moderate or severe hardship; and 89 percent called the cost of living a crucial or major factor in their vote. Much of the anti-tariff sentiment reflects a conflation of the tariffs with the real inflation accelerant, the Iran energy shock, which has pushed gasoline prices up 37 percent from a year ago.

Industrial Evidence of a Manufacturing Renaissance

Evidence suggests tariffs are catalyzing an American manufacturing renaissance. The ISM manufacturing index has stayed above 50, the threshold for expansion, for ten straight months. The October jobs report added 19,000 manufacturing jobs, bringing the 2026 gain to 101,000. Manufacturing employment is now 8,000 above its January 2025 level after last year's decline.

Growth in Nonresidential Specialty-Trade Contractors

Employment among nonresidential specialty-trade contractors, a broader category that includes workers on industrial projects, has risen nearly 120,000 since Trump took office. Equipment investment surged at a 21 percent annualized pace in the third quarter, with industrial equipment up nearly 25 percent.

Fiscal Impact of Tariffs

The Office of Management and Budget estimates that tariffs could contribute as much as $3 trillion to the Treasury over the next ten years. This revenue can fund investment and strengthen fiscal capacity.

Conclusion: Tariffs as a Tool for Reindustrialization

The lesson from November's election is that tariffs remain a central instrument of America's reindustrialization and manufacturing renaissance. They help reshape supply chains, promote domestic manufacturing, and enhance national security. The message is to ignore political spin and continue the course.

Background: Who Is Peter Navarro?

Peter Navarro, the White House senior counselor for trade and manufacturing, has long advocated for tariffs as a tool to protect American jobs. He has worked in trade policy for the U.S. Treasury and has authored several books on the subject.

What Happens Next?

As the new administration moves forward, policymakers will need to balance the benefits of tariffs with potential trade retaliation. The ongoing debate will shape future trade negotiations and domestic manufacturing policy.