Amazon MGM Studios film I Play Rocky is navigating discussions with the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences over whether Peter Gamble's script will compete as an original or adapted screenplay for the 99th Academy Awards. Thursday, Nov. 12, marks the final deadline for studios to submit Official Screen Credits forms to the Academy, though no final determination has been reached yet.
How the Script Was Written
Peter Gamble conceived and wrote the script as an original without basing it on a book, article, memoir, or other single published work. The writer drafted it on spec, and a spot on the Black List carried it to producers Christian Baha and Toby Emmerich and eventually to director Peter Farrelly. It stands as Gamble's second produced feature script following Office Uprising in 2018.
The Case for Adapted Screenplay
Rocky remains one of the most established pieces of intellectual property in Hollywood, and sources indicate some individuals within the organizations are weighing whether the screenplay fits the adapted category. Rocky Balboa, Adrian, and Apollo Creed are preexisting characters, and Peter Farrelly's film restages several of the 1976 movie's well-known scenes. Amazon MGM and the Academy declined to comment on the matter.
Writers Guild and Academy Rules
The film expands nationwide Nov. 20, the same day Writers Guild of America submissions close, but the guild will not weigh in because the movie was not produced under a WGA signatory agreement. That leaves the decision entirely to the Academy Writers Branch executive committee. The committee reviews each eligible title and generally defers to the WGA classification unless the guild has not classified a film or its classification has been called into question.
Precedents and Biopic Arguments
Greta Gerwig's Barbie was moved to adapted after Warner Bros. campaigned it as an original, similar to how Moonlight, Whiplash, and The Ballad of Buster Scruggs shifted categories. A strong counterargument exists because I Play Rocky is a biographical drama about a real person, and biopics like Milk and Darkest Hour routinely competed as originals.