# Susan Smith Denied Parole 32 Years After Drowning Her Two Young Sons

> Susan Smith, who drowned her two sons by rolling her car into a South Carolina lake in 1994, has been denied parole for the second time.

- Publisher: Briefzora (https://briefzora.com)
- URL: https://briefzora.com/susan-smith-denied-parole-32-years-after-drowning-her-two-young-sons
- Published: 2026-11-20T00:00:46+05:00
- Author: Briefzora Desk (https://briefzora.com/author/briefzora-desk)
- Section: World
- Topics: Police, Crime, Courts, Murderers and serial killers
- Image: https://briefzora.com/uploads/2026/11/mom-who-drowned-two-sons-3-14-months-denied-freedom-32-years-after-xedbbg.webp

## Key points

- Susan Smith was denied parole on Thursday, 32 years after murdering her two young sons.
- Her lawyers bizarrely argued that her mental health improved partly due to menopause.
- The parole board unanimously rejected her bid for freedom for the second time in two years.
- Her ex-husband David Smith and former prosecutor Tommy Pope strongly opposed her release.
- Her next chance at parole will come in 2028.

## Why it matters

The decision keeps Susan Smith behind bars for life after she deliberately drowned her two sons in 1994, sparing her grieving family from further public distress.

## Article

Susan Smith, 55, was refused parole on Thursday, 32 years after she murdered Michael, three, and 14-month-old Alex, while they were strapped into their car seats.

The convicted killer initially told law enforcement officers that a Black man had carjacked her vehicle and kidnapped the boys, which sparked a massive nine-day search before she eventually confessed to letting the car roll into the water.

## Parole Hearing Details and Arguments

Susan Smith appeared via video link from Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, South Carolina, for a hearing before the state parole board in Columbia. The inmate, who is serving a life sentence for the 1994 murders, begged to be released as her legal representatives argued that her mental health had dramatically improved.

In an unusual moment, Dr. Jessica Hill told the board that Susan Smith's mental illness had eased partly because of hormonal changes brought on by menopause. Hill said that Susan Smith had suffered from borderline personality disorder but argued that she had since matured out of the condition.

The psychiatrist also credited medication and the deaths of Susan Smith's mother and stepfather with helping stabilize her mental health. The psychiatrist pointed to Susan Smith's troubled childhood, including her father's suicide and sexual abuse by her stepfather. Susan Smith's lawyer argued that she had no other criminal history and would pose a low risk of committing another crime if released.

## Board Decision and Family Opposition

The killer mom's desperate plea failed to convince the board, which unanimously rejected her bid for freedom for the second time in two years. One parole board member recused herself from the decision because she had previously served as a warden at a prison where Susan Smith was held.

During the hearing, Susan Smith apologized for the murders and insisted she felt deep remorse for the cold-blooded killings. “I want to say I'm sorry to Michael and Alex. They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die,” she said. “I dropped to my lowest when I let that car go into that lake.”

She also apologized to her ex-husband David Smith, who appeared at the hearing to fight against her release. Susan Smith acknowledged that David had been robbed of the chance to watch their sons grow up, ride bicycles, and attend school. She claimed she had changed during her time in prison and wanted to help others if she was ever released.

But David delivered an emotional plea to the board, insisting that more than three decades behind bars was nowhere near enough punishment. “I know to some of you that 32 years is a long time. But for me, it's yesterday,” he said. “She took away one of the greatest gifts that God gives us, is life. She did that deliberately. It wasn't an accident. It wasn't a bad mistake.”

He added that granting her parole would be a “huge injustice” to Michael and Alex. David was joined by his wife Tiffany, their 25-year-old daughter Savannah, and other loved ones who urged officials to keep Susan Smith locked up.

Former prosecutor Tommy Pope also spoke against her release, saying, “Susan made the choice out of selfishness.” He claimed she believed she could start over with someone else by getting rid of her children, which Susan Smith fiercely denied. Pope also raised fears that Susan Smith could exploit her notoriety if released, accusing her of having enjoyed the national media attention surrounding the case.

He warned that her release could force the victims' family to endure seeing Susan Smith speaking publicly about the murders online. “If you think this family's been through hell now, imagine every day if you pick up your phone or you turn on your computer and there's Susan talking,” he told the board. The board was told that 10,845 petition statements had been submitted by people opposing her release.

## Background of the 1994 Murders

On October 25, 1994, Susan Smith drove her maroon Mazda to a boat ramp at John D. Long Lake in Union County, South Carolina. She allowed the vehicle to roll into the water while Michael and Alex remained helplessly strapped into their car seats. A chilling reconstruction by investigators later showed that it took about six minutes for the car to sink beneath the surface.

Cameras fitted inside the vehicle during the reconstruction captured water pouring through the air vents and steadily rising as the Mazda disappeared underwater. When investigators recovered the car, the boys' bodies were found dangling upside down in their seats, with one tiny hand pressed against a window.

Susan Smith spent nine days pretending her children had been abducted, making tearful television appeals for their safe return as police searched for a nonexistent carjacker. She eventually confessed, leading investigators to recover the boys' bodies from the submerged vehicle. Prosecutors argued that Susan Smith wanted to pursue a relationship with another man who did not want children, while her defense claimed she had been suffering from severe mental health problems.

Her lawyers said she had originally intended to die alongside her sons but changed her mind at the last moment. A jury convicted her of two counts of murder in 1995 but spared her the death penalty, instead sentencing her to life behind bars. She became eligible for parole after serving 30 years, but her first request for freedom was unanimously rejected in November 2024.

## What Happens Next

Thursday's rejection means Susan Smith must remain in prison for at least another two years, with her next chance at parole coming in 2028. Pope also told Thursday's hearing that he hoped to change South Carolina law to extend the time between parole hearings to three to five years, sparing the victims' family from having to relive the tragedy every two years.

## Frequently asked questions

### Why was Susan Smith denied parole?

The parole board unanimously rejected her bid for freedom after hearing opposing testimony from her ex-husband and a former prosecutor.

### When can Susan Smith apply for parole again?

Susan Smith must remain in prison for at least another two years, with her next chance at parole coming in 2028.


---

When citing, please link to https://briefzora.com/susan-smith-denied-parole-32-years-after-drowning-her-two-young-sons and name Briefzora as the source.
